Emerson and fleming, 1990 of group sequential trials. Trial sequential analysis represents analysis of metaanalytic data, with. Metaregression analyses, metaanalyses, and trial sequential. Coronary artery bypass surgery plus medical therapy versus. Ncss includes tools for performing groupsequential analysis of one or two means, two proportions, and two hazard rates. Effects of chloride content of intravenous crystalloid. Application of the trial sequential analysis software for. We define the required information size and the corresponding number of required trials in a meta analysis and the diversity d2 measure of heterogeneity. Thus a conclusion may sometimes be reached at a much earlier stage than would be. We explain the reasons for using trial sequential analysis of metaanalysis when the actual. Using randomeffects metaanalyses, metaregression analyses, and trial sequential analyses, we examined the association between betacarotene, vitamin a, and vitamin e, and mortality according to their daily doses and doses below and above the recommended daily allowances rda.
Trial sequential boundaries for cumulative metaanalyses. After n subjects in each group, are available, an interim analysis. Prognostic significance of expression in penile squamous. Designing, monitoring, and analyzing group sequential. Efficacy of perioperative dexmedetomidine on postoperative delirium. Relationship between auroraa v57i polymorphism and the risk. That clever idea is called sequential analysis and was introduced by abraham wald somebody we have written about before. Despite its possible benefits, its application in meta. Trial sequential analysis indicates that the effect was robust, and additional data are unlikely to alter the summary effect. If you have ever heard of a test plan such as first process to get more than 30 wins ahead of the other is the one we choose you have seen methods derived from walds sequential analysis technique. A total of 35 studies involving 3406 participants met the inclusion criteria for this meta analysis. Trial sequential analysis is a complex statistical tool that can be misused and has been criticised. Department of biostatistics and medical informatics technical report 177. Two investigators independently performed the literature search, study selection, data extraction, and quality evaluation.
Copenhagen trial unit, copenhagen, denmark, 2011 was applied to assess the risk of type i errors in the cumulative metaanalysis, which. Sequential monitoring boundaries can be applied to metaanalysis as well, called trial sequential monitoring boundaries. Researchers at the copenhagen trials unit extended these ideas to establish trial sequential analysis tsa. Rivaroxaban for thromboprophylaxis after total hip or knee. On the basis of the required information size, trial sequential monitoring boundaries can be constructed. Radiofrequency ablation versus hepatic resection for small. Blood purification and mortality in sepsis and septic shock. Request pdf application of the trial sequential analysis software for meta analysis the robustness of results of statistical analysis would be. Group sequential clinical trial designs for normally. The evaluation of imprecision is a key dimension of the grading of the confidence in the estimate. The hazard ratio data and trial sequential analysis data used to support the findings of this study are included within the article. This together with inconclusive results on trial sequential analysis suggests that the current aggregate randomized evidence cannot consistently refute potential positive or detrimental effects on mortality. Software for biostatistics unc gillings school of global.
Nevertheless, sequential metaanalyses with the tsa software may. Once obrienfleming monitoring boundary is crossed, this suggests statistical significance for results adjusted for multiple comparisons. Department of biostatistics and medical informatics. The analysis can be performed with count data or on the hazard scale for timeto event data. Perform an analysis after all patients have been assessed.
Trial sequential analysis confirmed a rr reduction of 15 per cent for the use of tcs. The probability that the trial would continue to each analysis as a function of the hypothesized treat. Effects of lowdose computed tomography on lung cancer. On the basis of the required information size, trial sequential monitoring. Sequential monitoring boundaries can be applied to meta analysis as well, called trial sequential monitoring boundaries. Tsa was carried out by the statistical software, tsa version 0. Trial sequential analysis tsa combines a priori information on size calculation for a metaanalysis, with the adaptation of monitoring boundaries to evaluate the.
Blue line indicates cumulative z score, which shows the results for ponv cross the obrienfleming monitoring boundary diagonal red line and information size vertical red line. May 20, 2019 trial sequential analysis has previously been described as a hybrid position between frequentist and bayesian approaches, with the sequential analysis arising from frequentist statistics, and the bayesian component arising from a single a priori effect estimate of the intervention although bayesian analysis incorporates multiple prior. From group sequential designs to sample size reestimation nquery has it. Showing trial sequential monitoring boundaries for benefit and harm in a cumulative meta analysis. Mar 23, 2016 the effects of berries consumption on cardiovascular disease cvd risk factors have not been systematically examined. This is a cumulative random effects metaanalysis method that estimates a required information size i. Trial sequential analysis provides a frequentistic approach to control both type i and type ii errors. Trial sequential analysis tsa was performed using tsa 0. There was decreased risk of pod with dexmedetomidine use for the entire adult surgical population odds ratio or 0. The data supporting this metaanalysis are from previously reported studies. We define the required information size and the corresponding number of required trials in a metaanalysis. Trial sequential analyses were performed including all trials and considering only low risk of bias trials.
In the design phase, an initial calculation of the sample size needed if the final stage is reached is made. Group sequential clinical trial design with the rctdesign package, 2 emerson, 2003, and analysis whitehead, 1986b. Trial sequential analysis tsa has been advocated for a more reliable assessment of imprecision. You can manage this and all other alerts in my account.
Copenhagen trial unit, copenhagen, denmark, 2011 was applied to assess the risk of type i errors in the cumulative meta analysis, which combined an estimation of required information size with an adjusted threshold for statistical significance with dispersed data 18,19. Provides a wide variety of options for normal and binomial endpoints in superiority, noninferiority, and equivalence studies. Trial sequential analysis estimation of required sample. Sequential is an east module for planning, simulating, monitoring and communicating group sequential clinical trial designs. Sample size software for adaptive clinical trial designs. A relative risk reduction of 10% was considered as the clinically meaningful difference in the primary outcome. Trial sequential analysis estimation of required sample size in metaanalysis wang quan1, 2, 4, tian jinhui1,4, li lun1,2,4, he xiran3, huang di1, 4, ge long1, 2, 4, yang kehu1,2 1. Thus, the trial sequential analysis software tsa, version 0. Request pdf application of the trial sequential analysis software for metaanalysis the robustness of results of statistical analysis would be. If you have ever heard of a test plan such as first process. Trial sequential analysis enables testing for significance to be conducted each time a new trial is included in the meta analysis. Mar 29, 2016 rivaroxaban for thromboprophylaxis after total hip or knee arthroplasty.
Trial sequential analysis tsa is a methodology that combines an information size calculation cumulated sample sizes of all included trials for a metaanalysis with the threshold of statistical significance. Trial sequential analysis tsa, copenhagen, dk was conducted for comparisons with a minimum of five studies to assess the cumulative evidence according to the information size achieved to date 15. Through statas metan command, metacumbounds plots the landemets bounds, z values, and p values obtained from both fixed and randomeffects cumulative metaanalyses. We also performed trial sequential analysis tsa, a method that combines the a priori information size with repeated significance testing on accumulating data, to correct for the increased risk of random errors and to clarify if more trials were needed. The funnel plot approach was used to investigate publication bias if we included more than 10 studies in. Each time a document was removed for sensitivity analysis. When the cumulative zcurve crosses the trial sequential monitoring boundary or enters the futility area, this indicates that. Corresponding to each ncss procedure for groupsequential analysis, there exists a companion procedure in pass sample size software for making this calculation. Application of the trial sequential analysis software for meta analysis. This analysis was performed using trial sequential analysis software, version 0. Several empirical studies have demonstrated that the trial sequential analysis provides better control of type i errors and of type ii errors than the traditional naive metaanalysis. Trial sequential analysis for inhospital mortality. Jinhuang powder for the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers. Several empirical studies have demonstrated that the trial sequential.
We use eggers test and beggs funnel chart to evaluate the publication of bias. In tsa the addition of each trial in a cumulative metaanalysis is regarded as. The analysis can be performed with count data or on the hazard scale for timetoevent data. Association of corticosteroid treatment with outcomes in. In tsa the addition of each trial in a cumulative meta analysis is regarded as an interim meta analysis and tsa controls the risks for type i and type ii errors and helps to clarify whether additional trials are needed. Clinical efficacy of extracorporeal cardiopulmonary. Risk ratios rrs and mean differences mds with 95% confidence intervals cis were estimated with fixed or random effects models. Application of the trial sequential analysis software for metaanalysis. Frontiers probiotics for preventing ventilatorassociated. Grading of recommendations assessment, development and evaluation grade gives recommendations on how to downgrade evidence for imprecision, but authors vary in their use. Efficacy of perioperative dexmedetomidine on postoperative.
East extension modules guide trial planners through the myriad of design options while offering more adaptive, group sequential and fixedsample size clinical designs than any other commercial software package. Group sequential clinical trial designs for normally distributed outcome variables michael grayling james wason adrian mander hub for trials methodology research mrc biostatistics unit cambridge, uk stata uk users group meeting, september 2017 m. It computes a variety of simple and contingency table statistics. We performed trial sequential analysis for outcomes that were reported by at least four rcts using trial sequential analysis software 0. Finally, three rcts with 198 participants were included. The generalized sequential querier is a computer program for analyzing sequential observational data. Hemodynamic goaldirected therapy and postoperative kidney. Trial sequential analysis has previously been described as a hybrid position between frequentist and bayesian approaches, with the sequential analysis arising from frequentist statistics. We present a new command, metacumbounds, for the estimation of trial sequential monitoring boundaries in cumulative metaanalyses. Tsa was performed based on a relative risk reduction of inhospital mortality of 6. Metaanalysis, metaregression, and trial sequential analysis you will receive an email whenever this article is corrected, updated, or cited in the literature. Five trials examining 742 patients were included in this study sizes of trials.
Software for design and analysis of group sequential clinical trials with multiple primary endpoints. Relationship between auroraa v57i polymorphism and the. Trial sequential analysis tsa combines a priori information on size calculation for a meta analysis, with the adaptation of monitoring boundaries to evaluate the accumulated evidence. Trial sequential analysis enables testing for significance to be conducted each time a new trial is included in the metaanalysis. Here, we aimed to conduct a metaanalysis with trial sequential. Jun 26, 2019 primary outcome was acute kidney injury, whichever definition was used. Rivaroxaban for thromboprophylaxis after total hip or knee arthroplasty. Instead data are evaluated as they are collected, and further sampling is stopped in accordance with a predefined stopping rule as soon as significant results are observed. Drugs for treating severe hypertension in pregnancy.
These findings do not support the use of polymyxin b immobilized fiber column hemoperfusion in sepsis and septic shock. The sample set extracted from 24 casecontrol studies involving 35,926 subjects. Metaanalysis and trial sequential analysis tsa were used to examine the impact. Grading of recommendations assessment, development and evaluation grade gives. Trial sequential analysis tsa was used to access whether the sample size of our metaanalysis was sufficient. The data supporting this metaanalysis are from previously reported studies and datasets, which have been cited.
The approach is based on the landemets method for estimating group sequential boundaries in individual randomized controlled trials by using the package ldbounds in r statistical software. Jul 28, 2018 the evaluation of imprecision is a key dimension of the grading of the confidence in the estimate. Mar 05, 2018 in a randomized trial with two treatment groups, group sequential testing may for example be conducted in the following manner. Group sequential clinical trial designs for normally distributed outcome variables. The meta analysis, power analysis and trial sequential analysis tsa were performed by using meta analyst software version beta 3. Using randomeffects metaanalyses, metaregression analyses, and trial sequential analyses, we examined the association between betacarotene, vitamin a, and vitamin e, and mortality according to. In a randomized trial with two treatment groups, group sequential testing may for example be conducted in the following manner. Blood purification and mortality in sepsis and septic. A metaanalysis with trial sequential analysis hindawi. Design, analysis, and reporting of such trials well. Design and analysis of group sequential clinical trials with multiple primary endpoints. Evidencebased medicine center of school of basic medical science, lanzhou university, lanzhou 730000, china 2. Dec 11, 2015 that clever idea is called sequential analysis and was introduced by abraham wald somebody we have written about before. East extension modules guide trial planners through the myriad of design options while offering more adaptive, group sequential and fixedsample size clinical designs than any other commercial software.
Trial sequential analysis tsa was performed to assess the quantity and strength of. In statistics, sequential analysis or sequential hypothesis testing is statistical analysis where the sample size is not fixed in advance. For readers wishing to learn more about the underlying principles and conduct of tsa, the software and manual can be freely downloaded from. Here, we aimed to conduct a meta analysis with trial sequential analysis to. The metaanalysis was performed by using software, and trial sequential analysis tsa was performed. We conducted tsa using trial sequential analysis software 0. Designing, monitoring, and analyzing group sequential clinical. Prognostic significance of expression in penile squamous cell. The metaanalysis, power analysis and trial sequential analysis tsa were performed by using meta analyst software version beta 3. Effects of berries consumption on cardiovascular risk factors. Eighteen studies comprising 3309 patients were included. The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
We explain the reasons for using trial sequential analysis of meta analysis when the. Does ondansetron modify sympathectomy due to subarachnoid. Showing trial sequential monitoring boundaries for benefit and harm in a cumulative metaanalysis. Effects of berries consumption on cardiovascular risk. Sensitivity analyses were performed to examine the robustness of the effect size. Primary outcome was acute kidney injury, whichever definition was used. Metaanalytic techniques analysis software revman, version 5.
759 1416 1633 1533 951 968 383 967 522 418 755 603 414 737 1011 1028 854 268 671 1417 858 1197 1411 550 742 1162 626 407 242 1016 441 522 918 904 1250 805 615 174 475 139 1342 960 321 173 1352